Hello dear
Welcome To Pegasus Pizza
At Pegasus Pizza, we intertwine passion for good food with a commitment to quality, delivering exceptional pizzas right from Morton, IL. Our story is rooted in the belief that every bite should burst with flavor, from the crispy crust to our special cheese blend. With crowd favorite specialty pizzas like the Imperial, packed with ham, sausage, and extra cheese, it’s no wonder locals deem us the best pizza in town. While we focus on providing takeout and delivery, our friendly staff ensures each order is cooked to perfection—making any meal with us a memorable experience worth raving about.
About
Pegasus Pizza
If you’re in Morton, Illinois, and have a craving for pizza, look no further than Pegasus Pizza. Nestled at 151 W Bradley St, this local gem is dedicated to crafting delicious pizzas that keep customers coming back for more. Known for their consistently hot and tasty offerings, Pegasus Pizza is heralded as the best pizza in town by enthusiastic patrons.
One of the standout aspects of Pegasus Pizza is their exceptional crust. Customers like Eric Lyons rave about its perfect crispiness, a testament to the quality and care that goes into each pie. Each pizza is made with a distinct cheese blend, adding a fantastic flavor profile that elevates the overall experience. With prices starting as low as $9.45 for a 12-inch cheese pizza, there’s something for everyone.
Pegasus Pizza boasts a selection of specialty pizzas that cater to a variety of tastes. From the hearty Imperial Pizza featuring ham, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, and extra cheese to the indulgent Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza loaded with beef, bacon, onion, and extra cheese, there’s no shortage of flavor or creativity. Each pie is crafted with quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite is delicious.
For those looking to feed a crowd, Pegasus Pizza offers enticing pair prices, making it easy to share the love— and the pizza! Eric Lyons and Shawn Schoonveld emphasize that although there isn’t a dining area, the pizza is so good you might find yourself enjoying it right in your car. The pickup-only model contributes to the swift service, although Timothy Thompson humorously notes that sometimes the wait can feel long given how popular they are.
Moreover, the skilled staff at Pegasus Pizza have received consistent accolades for their friendly service and efficiency. As Sarah Hulen’s experience illustrates, whether you're picking up five pizzas for a gathering or grabbing one for yourself, the quality is always top-notch. She even mentions driving 25 minutes out of her way for a taste of what they offer. That kind of dedication speaks volumes about the satisfaction customers find here.
- Location: 151 W Bradley St, Morton, IL 61550
- Contact: (309) 263-7700
- Highlight Items:
- Cheese Only Pizza (12") - $9.45
- Imperial Pizza - $13.65
- Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza - $13.65
In the world of pizza, Pegasus Pizza has marked its territory as a must-try destination for both locals and travelers. With its commitment to quality, fantastic flavors, and unparalleled customer service, it truly stands out in Morton’s culinary scene. Don’t miss the chance to experience the magic of Pegasus Pizza; your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ The absolute best pizza in Morton. Undisputed champ! The pizza always comes hot, is consistently good, and they are usually spot on with how long the delivery will take. The crust is crispy and Im not sure what cheese blend they use but it has a fantastic flavor. Highly recommend this place to local residents and travelers! ”
“ It takes forever to get your pizza. If you can get a hold of them, it can be hard to get through but rest assured that is because its the best darn pizza in town and the staff runs like clock work. Its great pizza without the corporate BS. That dig was at you Caseys. ”
“ Excellent pizza! Decided to stop while traveling through Peoria and it was great pizza. Really friendly staff also. There is no dinein area but this place is still more than worth it. Stop in and eat the pizza in your car if you have to, its worth it. ”
“ Tried tonight for the first time after the Festival of Lights. Bought 5 pizzas to feed 13 people and each one was cooked to perfection! Very much enjoyed and will drive 25 minutes out of my way to enjoy it again. ”
“ Absolute best pizza in Morton! Staff is very friendly. Place is pickup counter only, so there is no seating, just an fyi. I always get the Large mushroom pizza. Would highly recommend them! ”
“ The Imperial Pizza was very good. The crust was thin and perfect. Definitely worth coming back. ”
“ Just an old pizza kitchen that serves the best pizza in Morton and the surrounding area, no contest!!! Forget the others and order Pegasus. No this was NOT a paid or incentivized review. Myself and a couple coworkers look forward to every Wednesday late night at work so we can order pizzas for dinner! ”
“ When my husband was a kid in the 80s there was a Pegasus Pizza in Lincoln that was his absolute favorite. We recently discovered that there is currently a Pegasus Pizza in Morton, same sign out front. We were excited to give it a try last ... ”